Jefferson Fire Fighters Association

"See through the smoke"

SALARY AND OVERTIME ISSUES

Jefferson Parish proposes to eliminate fire personnel's customary 5% annual increases currently received by all Jefferson Parish employees and plans to see only fire personnel reduced to 2% annual increases.

After receiving only $16.00 per month (a 1.5% increase in their pay plan) from 1990-2007, Jefferson’s East Bank Consolidated firefighters finally saw their pay plan adjusted in January 2007, amounting to a 35% increase. Fire personnel saw their incomes shrink by approximately 82% due to inflation during the 17 year period.

A salary study review ordered by Parish President Aaron Broussard addressing substandard wages for fire personnel, was extensive in scope and included surveys from more than 20 similarly sized fire departments in the southern region of the United States. The pay study, authorized prior to Hurricane Katrina, was finally concluded in October 2006. 

The salary study was provided by L-Staff, a certified employee compensation management company. The reviewer thoroughly researched and provided recommendations in a comprehensive report.  Jefferson Fire Fighters Association President Robert Burkett along with Parish President Aaron Broussard had agreed to accept and enact the findings of the study. The new pay plan was unanimously adopted by the Jefferson Parish Council with an effective date of January 1, 2007.  

In 1976 East Bank Consolidated fire personnel were confronted with similar injustices of reductions from a 5%, to the State required 2%, minimal annual increases. Jefferson Fire Fighters Association, led by former president Tom West, filed suit seeking relief in court demanding the protections of Louisiana State Fire Civil Service. (West versus Allen)  When former Parish President Joe Yenni was elected, he agreed to look into this reduction and promised to restore the annual 5% raises, if his investigation revealed Eastbank Consolidated firefighters had been treated unfairly. In 1980 he fulfilled his promise to reinstitute the 5% raises.

And now, 33 years later, freelancing, incompetent Jefferson Parish Fire administrators led by Interim Fire Director Dave Saunders, suggest again, without warning or conducting any studies, the same dramatic reduction in the firefighter’s current pay plan, less than two years after its revision.

This proposal is obviously a retaliatory action against firefighters for having the courage to speak out about safety issues, unwise spending, planning, neglect, bad decisions, and a basic mismanagement of the fire department.  On April 7, 2008, Jefferson Fire Fighters Association appealed in writing to Jefferson Parish President Broussard, the Council and administrators for assistance in correcting firefighter issues.  They were informed of serious challenges that would negatively impact emergency services and the general public, who are dependent on the protection of the fire department.   A committee of active rank and file personnel was established to collect a delineation of concerns for submission to the Parish officials.  

The members of the Jefferson Fire Fighters Association have appealed to the administrators responsible for both causing and neglecting the members’ concerns; however, Interim Director Dave Saunders and CAA Deano Bonano have proved unwilling and unable to correct the flawed management of the Eastbank Consolidated Fire Department.  

 

Fire administrators are advertising grossly inflated East Jefferson fire salaries. Beginning with Hurricane Katrina, higher annual incomes occured because of the unprecedented availability of unscheduled overtime. FEMA reimbursed Jefferson Parish for unscheduled overtime during Hurricane Katrina, and its aftermath. Now, fire administrators are including similarly unscheduled, additional overtime hours to escalate the customary scheduled overtime costs; they fail to mention that many of the additional unscheduled overtime costs were repaid to the department by outside agencies, and in some instances, Eastbank Consolidated Fire Department realized a profit when they billed for unscheduled overtime. Failing to hire personnel by administrators, continued the need to utilize fire personnel for excessive amounts of unscheduled overtime.

Firefighters were called on to help Jefferson Parish fill positions for fire watches, inspections, dispatching, and manning fire stations during training classes. Surprisingly, none of these overtime hours were used to avoid shutting down first line fire apparatus when manpower was short.

Bogus attempts to mislead the public are alarming enough, but Jefferson Parish administrators refused to hire firefighters to fill openings for almost 3 years, which is in violation of Civil Service regulations.  Mismanagement caused fire crews to operate 19 positions short, amounting to approximately 10% of the fire suppression work force. The actual average salary calculations on display by Jefferson Parish are skewed by the elimination of 10% of the lowest salaried employees and the inclusion of a tremendous amount of unscheduled overtime.  

SCHEDULE AND OVERTIME ISSUES

Jefferson Parish proposes changes to a  firefighter’s schedule that will financially harm firefighter families, under the pretense of budgetary restrictions, while incompetent Eastbank Consolidated Fire Department administrators waste tax dollars on a daily basis. Jefferson firefighters have worked the same schedule for almost 50 years.  Three shifts work (24 hours on and 24 hours off) until they work a total of five 24 hour shifts. Each shift rotates out for 6 days and the rotation continues during a firefighter’s career.     

Jefferson Parish wants the public to believe firefighters are being paid for overtime they don’t actually work. Regular hours and scheduled overtime hours have never been defined. A total of 8.5 hours of scheduled overtime is included in the figures of an average 56.5 hour work week; there is no way to distinguish which hours are overtime hours. The scheduled, guaranteed 8.5 hours of overtime is a major part of firefighter salaries. Firefighters work an average of 16.5 hours over a 40 hour standard work week in the private sector. Jefferson Parish knows it would be illegal to pay firefighters for hours of work they are not entitled to.  

 

Professional fire departments use the assumption of an average 56.5 hour work week in calculating firefighter pay. Fire personnel are paid 8.5 hours of scheduled overtime per week, even though, they might work as many as 96 hours, or as few as 24 hours in a week. Scheduled overtime is included in firefighter’s regular pay schedule. The Louisiana Firefighters Retirement System recognizes scheduled overtime pay as regular salary.   

 

Jefferson Parish attempts to confuse the public about the difference of scheduled overtime and unscheduled overtime and proposes to eliminate firefighters’ scheduled overtime. Unscheduled overtime is different from scheduled overtime and is calculated as extra pay for additional duty, separate from a firefighter’s regular, scheduled overtime. (Vacation and illness or injury leave that firefighters earn, allows firefighters to take time off of their average 56.5 hour work week with no loss of their regular pay, in accordance with Louisiana State Law (R.S. 33:1995).

 

The only way a firefighter can earn additional pay over his regular salary is to work unscheduled overtime.  Jefferson Parish’s high priced PR firm is capitalizing on the pay plan’s complexities to mislead the public.  

     

 In 1993, Jefferson Parish contracted with MMA, a consulting firm to study fire and rescue services parish wide. The study found the Eastbank Consolidated Fire Department’s current schedule was “most appropriate” and recommended its continuance.  It was concluded; the Eastbank Consolidated firefighter’s work schedule, with its mandatory scheduled overtime, was the most flexible and cost effective approach to provide the level of protection East Jefferson businesses and residents pay for and deserve.

 

The proposal by fire administrators ignores the recommendations of the MMA Fire Study and is designed to eliminate scheduled overtime and will result in substantial reductions in firefighter salaries.  Fire service will be reduced or taxpayers will pay much higher manpower costs. No other Jefferson Parish pay plan has ever been modified without a thorough independent review or study.